Book Review: “The Thief” by Megan Whalen Turner


This is where you earn your reputation.

Title: The Thief
Series: 1st in The Queen’s Thief series, but can be read by itself
Author: Megan Whalen Turner
Pages: 219
Published: 1996
Spoiler-free Synopsis: The self-proclaimed “greatest thief in Sounis,” Gen is moldering in the King’s prison when the magus, the King’s highest advisor, sets him free in return for his aid on a very secret and difficult journey. But on this quest for a hidden treasure, politics, myth, and personal motives entwine dangerously…
Reason for Beginning: Recommended by Urania of The Egotist’s Club (who kindly bought me the book!); also the plot sounded interesting.
Reason for Finishing: Fast, fun, intriguing read. The character of Gen is the most interesting aspect of the book, but the others don’t disappoint either. The book has a good mix of adventure, humor, and heavier dramatic intrigue, but overall it veers towards “light” adventure rather than a “dark and grim” one.
Story Re-readability: Reasonably high, I’d say. I do intend to reread it eventually, to get more of the subtleties and to spot clues regarding the twists in the story, but isn’t exerting as massive a draw on me as, say, McKillip’s Bell at Sealey Head or a Sutcliff book. It’s fast-paced and well-written, though, so a reread should go quickly. Plus, it is entertaining.
Author Re-readability: Again, reasonably high. Her style isn’t as immediately impressive as Peter Beagle’s, Rosemary Sutcliff’s, or even Patricia McKillip’s (despite her modesty), but it’s clear, effective, and has more subtleties than you might notice at first. Her great skill seems to be sketching out lively, layered characters, but she can handle world-building, landscapes, and suspense very well, too, as needed. I’m interested in the rest of The Queen’s Thief series, but this book is a complete story in itself and needs no continuation.
Recommendation: Sure. It’s suitable for young teenagers but intelligent and entertaining enough for adults, too. It’s good, solid, and very enjoyable.

Here’s the book trailer put out by the publishers.

Key Thoughts

Here we have a clever little adventure that manages to provide some genuine surprises even up to the very end. The book’s centerpiece is its protagonist, Gen (short for Eugenides), apparently the greatest thief in the kingdom of Sounis. He narrates the story, and what I find amazing is how well we get to know him without really learning much about him. Oh, we know what he looks like (a short, non-muscular adventure hero! Finally!), and we become very familiar with his distinct personality. We even hear some stories and memories of his past, although distinguishing between facts and fiction is trickier than you might think at first.

He’s a master manipulator, actually. He’s brash, arrogant, and insouciant; but he is also sensible, perceptive, and passionate. He doesn’t care if you call him a coward, because he considers it practical to be afraid of things that can hurt you. He doesn’t mind if you think him weak or spoiled, either—he will complain until he gets the comforts he thinks are reasonable, and satisfies himself with the knowledge that he can always get revenge later. He’s irreverent towards almost everything, especially people with power. Even if you beat him up, he’ll still send back a snarky comment. In short, he should be quite unlikable, but he isn’t. He’s funny, he’s fascinating, and surprisingly sympathetic. We’re allowed to see fairly deeply into his mind, as he seems to hold little back in showing us the world through his eyes. And yet, it is only when we reach the end that we realize how little about him we know. Even as much gets revealed, it is clearly only the tip of an iceberg. I found all of this delightful. Gen is still a hero at the end, but not a typical one. He’s immensely fun to read about, but would probably be a trial to have as a personal friend.

‘Do you think I want everyone in the city to know that you are out working for the king?’
‘Why not?’
‘Do you announce that you’re going off to steal something before you start?’ He thought for a second. ‘Yes, you do. Well, I don’t.’
‘Why not?’ I asked again.

The world Turner creates in The Thief is deliberately anachronistic. On the one hand, it’s a loose recreation of ancient Greece, with the kingdoms of Sounis, Eddis, and Attolia being about the size of powerful city-states, and the landscape full of sun-baked olive trees, rocky hills, dusty mountains, and a glittering inland sea always on the horizon. The myths of the land also resemble Greek myths of quarreling gods and humans struggling to make their fame without offending heaven. On the other hand, gunpowder, the printing press, and complex locks all make an appearance. In truth, I found this jarring and unnecessary. I will allow Turner the more modern locks so that Gen can do the lockpicking that is expected of him, but the presence of gunpowder is too inconsequential to the story, and too radical a technology for the setting, that I didn’t feel it had a reason to be there. It felt like an arbitrary anachronism. It doesn’t really hurt the story, per se, it just feels gratuitous, in a story that is otherwise very streamlined.

Her prose, as I said above, is clear and suitable for the story. There are a few sections where characters tell each other myths about the gods of the land, and Turner writes well in that sparse, casual style so common to the most fantastic tales of old. She’s created her own mythology, but wisely shows off only those elements of relevance to her story. We get the feel of a real world, without being overburdened with superfluous names and details.

The Thief is an entertaining, skillfully-plotted book, with twists and turns you aren’t even aware of until they’re past, and an ending that ties everything up (or almost everything) in a satisfactory, enlightening package. That even the plot twists deepen our perceptions of the characters says much for Turner’s ability to write lively, multi-faceted personalities. Try it out for yourself.

Advertisements

Author: David

I’m a young Christian American reader writer dreamer wanderer walker flier listener talker scholar adventurer musician word-magician romantic critic religious idealist optipessimist man.

7 thoughts on “Book Review: “The Thief” by Megan Whalen Turner”

  1. Yay! I’m glad that this book gets some praise. I’ve been wanting to read it, but have been wary of picking it up because it seems to fall solidly in the YA genre, which seems to become more angsty with each passing book that I pick up.

    So, guess this means I have another book to request at the library!

    1. Not too much angst in this one, fortunately! That’s part of what I liked about it. Gen is forthright and brutally honest most of the time, even regarding his weaknesses (and how he doesn’t like being reminded of them). He doesn’t brood, he sulks, but in a way that’s funny and that actually serves plot purposes. ANYway, yes, I enjoyed it muchly, and I think you might too. Plus, as I said, it’s a quick read!

    1. You know, I feel so stupid because I didn’t even realize it until after finishing it and talking to you again. *slaps forehead* Duh! It is a fun reference, though. I just know that Sutcliff references are going to be popping up in my stories, whether I intend them or not, so it’s fun to find them in other peoples’ stories.

      Thanks; in general I try to avoid plot summary, as I dislike reading it in other reviews (and usually skip it), but it was especially important here to not reveal all.

      1. David! I can’t believe it! Well, okay, maybe I noticed the reference so quickly because I can be a bit of a magpie when it comes to jewelry, and my sister and I have always thought that Marcus’s ring would be a really cool piece to get a jeweler to make.

        Thus far, I’ve worked a few Sutcliff references into my own stories. For example, Lithium’s family name is Silverbranch. And the phrase “two inches in the right spot” probably will make it into something at some point. Perhaps that’s a kind of standard expression to say “it doesn’t take much to kill somebody,” but it is a line from one of her books (can’t remember which one–Frontier Wolf?), and I’m pretty darn sure it shows up later in the Thief books. Hah, just Googled it, and it turns out that it’s from the Latin phrase “Duas uncias in puncta mortalis est.” Huzzah for classical education!

  2. Have you had a chance to read the rest of the books in the series yet? If you haven’t, I can’t recommend them highly enough. I like that Turner acknowledges her readers’ intelligence by weaving subtle plots — she’s not one to lead her readers by the hand or insert giant blinking neon signs that scream plot point. It’s this kind of writing that allows you to read a book again and again and get something different out of it every time. And don’t get me started on the characters. Like you said, Gen is such a whiner, a trait I normally find absolutely annoying, but I can’t help but find it endearing in him. He only becomes more complex and awesome in books two, three, and four (though the fourth book is not really his story, but Sophos’). I think the best part about these books may just be the dialogue, though. I have countless passages underlined in all of the books.

    I’m going to stop gushing now, though I must say it’s nice to see some love for The Bell at Sealey Head. I read it sometime last year and I adored it. Plus, it had a gorgeous cover (I’m a bit of a nerd for that). All of her covers are quite lovely for that matter, except the original cover for The Riddlemaster of Hed, which was shockingly bad.

    1. No, I haven’t read anything else by Turner yet. Too much else on my reading list at the moment. But she interested me in her characters, so I do hope to return to them before too long. Thanks for the recommendation.

      Have you seen my review of The Bell at Sealey Head? I loved it, too. In fact, I wrote about it twice in the 2012 Book Meme that I finished not too long ago with some other bloggers (you can see all the topics if you click the Page at the top of my header). The cover is beautiful, I agree. At first I thought it was an actual painting from the Romantic era that just happened to fit, but nope, it was commissioned special for the book. I’d love to see covers as nice as that for my books, when I get them written and published.

What are your thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s