Book Meme Day 14: My Favorite Books by my Favorite Writers

From Tolkien, The Silmarillion.

In addition to containing one of my favorite stories, period, in Of Beren and Lúthien, the book also contains all the best, most formative stories of Tolkien’s mythology of Arda (the term referring to his entire invented world, of which Middle-Earth is but a continent). The Ainulindalë section, in which the world is created by musical worship of God, has a majesty reminiscent of the Book of Revelation. The story of the Elves’ Awakening by the twilit lake of Cuiviénen makes me long for a place of beauty that never was, and sad for the Avari, the so-called “refusers” who stayed behind when their cousins, the Noldor (High Elves), followed Oromë to Valinor, because they dwindled into obscurity and were forgotten (unless they are in fact the later Sindarin “Grey Elves,” which would mean they did not dwindle but forged some great kingdoms of their own, including that of Mirkwood from which comes Legolas). Also Fëanor, greatest of the Noldor and forger of the Silmarils, whose foolish rebellion against the Valar and leading of his people from the paradise of Valinor led only to suffering, anguish, and a deadly curse on his sons that would haunt Elves and Men for centuries. When the fair hidden city of Gondolin fell to a hellish onslaught by Morgoth, my heart ached at Arda’s loss. And so many others…the doom of Túrin Turambar, the travels of Tuor, the terrible battles of Dagor Bragollach and the Nirnaeth Arnoediad, the voyage of Eärendil the Mariner, and of course the rise and fall of Númenor.

These stories move me and fascinate me more than even the genuine mythologies of Greece, Rome, the Norse, and the Celts. One reason is that The Silmarillion’s myriad stories have a beautiful unity of theme and purpose concerning the rebellion of Elves against the purposes of Ilúvatar and their eventual redemption by his grace. The theme is drawn from the story of mankind’s own rebellion and redemption in the Holy Bible, and thus has a truly timeless quality.

From Lewis, while this is a tough decision, I shall have to say Perelandra.

Yeah, it's a really weird cover. Very psychedelic.

The second book of his Space Trilogy, it is essentially Lewis’ take on John Milton’s Paradise Lost, giving homage to that English epic while correcting many of its faults. But Lewis is not bound to the connections with Milton; his subject is the Fall of Man as told in Genesis. What has sin really done to humanity, after all? What might we have been like before our corruption, when we were perfect and in harmony with God and His creation? What is innocence, and can it be cunning? I love especially Lewis’ treatment of the idea of purity. The Lady, representing Eve, is utterly pure and innocent, not knowing evil or perversity in any form. Our modern culture looks condescendingly on these traits as naïve and therefore weaker than worldly wisdom. But Lewis proves otherwise. The Lady fends off the arguments of Satan handily, defeating his logic with the purity of her own and her faith in God. These passages are a delight to read, even as the tension grows because of our concern that Satan may succeed once again, as he did with Adam and Eve.

There are other reasons to love Perelandra. It is science fiction more concerned with theology and mythology than with science. On nearly every page there seems to be a groundbreaking or deeply profound idea. The landscape of the planet is unlike any I have read of before, with its gentle undulations that somehow do not cause seasickness, and the ending is surprisingly and utterly brilliant. There is so much depth and detail in it, that I think I shall need four or five rereads before I begin to understand more fully what Lewis has accomplished in it.

J. Holsworth Stevenson on The Silmarillion
J. Holsworth Stevenson on Out of the Silent Planet, the first book in the Space Trilogy of which Perelandra is second.


  1. Ahh! Two of favorites!!! For such different reasons . . . the Silmarillion for the absolute wealth of myth and history and characters and the interweaving of everything! What you said before about how none of these tales exist in a vacuum might be the reason why I love them so – everything has purpose and connection and reality! And as for Perelandra; my heart breaks every time I read it, but I cannot stop!

    Excellent choices. Well done. I approve!

  2. Ha! This is the second time I’ve overlapped on one of these…and may I say that the most delightful part of getting caught back up is finally getting to read Mel’s and your posts (which I refuse to read before reaching my own conclusions)…

    I do love the Silmarillion, but I feel like I must somehow be reading it the wrong way. The Ainulindale moves me to tears with its beauty, but somehow I end up exhausted before meeting all of the Valar, even. And thus do I miss out on appreciating the history of the elves…clearly it is time to reread it…

    Also you have my full agreement on the Perelandra cover. I’ve been staring at it at intervals over the past few days, wondering where the water is, why an apple comes into play at all, and what that weird white gazebo is…too weird.

    As for rereading, it just hit me today that one fun thing about CSL’s work is his background – that is, because he was so well-versed in all the great literature that came before him, reading such works will tend to deepen my appreciation for his writing and the allusions therein. Sure, it freaked me out in The Discarded Image, but taking Perelandra as a sort of response to Genesis, Paradise Lost, and other stories of temptation or redemption, tends to make all its profundities deeper yet.

    1. Aw, thanks. I love reading your guys’ posts too. If you don’t post early in the day, I end up checking back frequently. So much fun to compare. Of course I like when we overlap in interests, because then I get a different perspective on a book I already love, but it’s also great that you guys have a whole other set of authors you love and read that I haven’t got to yet. Reading those posts is a minor education. +)

      The Valaquenta in particular is very exhausting — I eventually skimmed quickly through the last half of it, skipping large sections. I’d like to go back and check it out, though, since the personalities of the Valar do play a large role in the drama of Beleriand. I’ll have to reread it also, since it was still before my historian training had set in that I read it first.

      Well the apple on the cover is clearly symbolic of the fruit that Eve ate from the Tree. Beyond that, I’ve no idea what’s going on. After all, that particular cover is from 1972…

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.